Review: Utility Cost Statement 2024 (Lindenallee 7, Apt. 3.2)
You, as a residential tenant, received a statement demanding €748.60. Arithmetic is correct, but there are several serious formal and content issues.
Key Findings
1. Statement received after the 12-month deadline — Critical
Period ended 31.12.2024, so the deadline under § 556(3) BGB was 31.12.2025. The letter is dated 05.01.2026; you state receipt on 07.01.2026 — 7 days late. Unless the landlord was not responsible for the delay, a back-payment is then generally excluded. Rechnerisch nach deinen Angaben; maßgeblich ist der tatsächliche Zugang. Lass die Frist sofort prüfen. Option: Point out the late receipt in writing and ask the landlord to confirm that no back-payment is claimed.
2. Heating costs distributed only by living area — Critical
Evidence: "Die Heizkosten wurden in diesem Jahr vollständig nach Wohnfläche verteilt". The Heating Cost Ordinance (HeizkostenV) requires 50–70% consumption-based distribution. Where this is violated, tenants may cut their share by 15% (§ 12 HeizkostenV) — here about €153.00.
3. Landlord refuses consumption-based statement — Warning
"Eine verbrauchsabhängige Abrechnung reichen wir nicht nach." A late meter reading is in the landlord's sphere. You can request the consumption data or rely on the 15% reduction.
4. Administration costs — Critical
"Verwaltungskosten | 5.580,00 €" (your share €306.00). Management costs are excluded from operating costs (§ 1(2) BetrKV) and are generally not allocable in residential leases.
5. Repair costs (gutter) — Critical
"Instandhaltung (Reparatur Dachrinne)" (€136.00). Repairs are not operating costs (§ 1(2) No. 2 BetrKV).
6. Cable TV for full year 2024 — Warning
"Kabelfernsehen (01.01.–31.12.2024)" (€93.00). Since 01.07.2024 no longer allocable; at most half (€46.50) appears permissible.
7. CO2 cost split not shown — Warning
Gas heating, but no CO2 split under the Carbon Dioxide Cost Allocation Act (CO2KostAufG) is shown. If missing, tenants may reduce the heating share by 3%. Ask for the CO2 figures.
8. Four-week objection period / "deemed accepted" — Warning
"innerhalb von vier Wochen … danach gilt die Abrechnung als anerkannt". The statutory objection period is 12 months; shorter periods to the tenant's disadvantage are likely ineffective (§ 556(4) BGB). Your period runs rechnerisch until 07.01.2027 — 47 days from today.
9. Copy charges and appointment requirement — Info
Appointment-based inspection at the office is usually acceptable. €2.50/page is well above amounts courts typically accept (order of magnitude €0.25–0.50); you may ask for a lower rate.
10. Further points — Info
- Prepayment increase to €275 (+31%) seems excessive; adjusted costs suggest about €219/month.
- €15 late fee and 14-day payment term: worth questioning; a reasonable review period is generally granted.
- Insurance, caretaker, garden etc.: unremarkable, but caretaker costs may not include repair/admin work.
- No § 35a EStG household services shown.
What's missing / not verifiable
- Prior-year statement (area, cost jumps)
- Exact lease wording on allocable costs
- Gas consumption, meter data, CO2 figures
- Proof of delivery date
What you can do
- Raise the deadline objection in writing (keep proof of receipt date).
- Object to admin, repair and second-half cable costs; cite the 15% heating reduction and CO2 split.
- Request receipts and question the prepayment increase.
- Consider advice from a tenants' association (Mieterverein).
Automated AI evaluation, not reviewed by a human; not legal advice.