Employment Contract Review – Software Developer (Backend)
The salary and holiday entitlement meet the legal minimums. However, the contract contains several standard clauses that clearly disadvantage you and that case law often views as invalid.
Key Findings
1. Contractual penalty of three gross monthly salaries – Critical
Evidence: § 11 "Vertragsstrafe in Höhe von drei Bruttomonatsgehältern" (12,600 €). Case law generally only accepts penalties up to roughly the pay for the applicable notice period. During probation that is about half a monthly salary. Penalties set this high are often considered disproportionate and invalid as a whole. Option: Ask for a cap at the pay for the notice period, or for the clause to be removed.
2. Employee notice period longer than employer's – Critical
Evidence: § 10: employer uses "gesetzlichen Fristen"; employee "drei Monaten zum Quartalsende". This appears to breach § 622(6) BGB. According to case law, the longer period would then also apply to the employer. It does not mean that a shorter period applies to you. In practice, the clause ties you to the employer for longer than you might expect. Option: Ask for the same notice period for both sides.
3. Exclusion period of only one month – Critical
Evidence: § 12 "innerhalb eines Monats nach Fälligkeit". Case law usually expects at least three months. The clause also does not exclude minimum wage claims or liability for intent, which are frequently cited reasons for invalidity. Even so, be aware that you could still be held to it in practice. Option: Request 3 months and the required exceptions.
4. Blanket overtime compensation without hour limit – Warning
Evidence: § 4 "sämtliche Überstunden und Mehrarbeit abgegolten". The clause gives no number of hours, so you cannot tell what you are being paid for. Case law often treats this as non-transparent and therefore invalid. Option: Ask for a fixed cap (e.g. a set number of hours per month) or for overtime to be paid or compensated with time off.
5. Obligation to work overtime without limits – Warning
Evidence: § 3 "bei betrieblichem Bedarf Mehrarbeit und Überstunden zu leisten". The clause sets no maximum. The Working Hours Act (Arbeitszeitgesetz) still applies: max. 10 hours per day and 11 hours of rest. Option: Ask for a cap and advance notice.
6. Complete ban on any side activity – Warning
Evidence: § 7 "Jede Nebentätigkeit … ist untersagt." A blanket ban that also covers unpaid activities is often considered invalid. Usually only a duty to notify or a requirement to obtain permission is accepted. Option: Suggest a notification duty instead.
7. Training cost repayment regardless of reason – Warning
Evidence: § 8 "vollständig … gleich aus welchem Grund", three years. The clause has no graduated reduction over time and also applies if the employer terminates you. According to case law, such clauses are usually invalid. Option: Ask for a pro-rata reduction and for repayment to apply only where you are responsible for the termination.
8. Christmas bonus: voluntary and revocable combined – Warning
Evidence: § 4 "freiwillig und unter dem Vorbehalt des jederzeitigen Widerrufs". Combining both reservations is contradictory and therefore non-transparent. In practice you should not count on receiving a bonus. Option: Ask whether a fixed bonus can be agreed.
9. Broad transfer clause nationwide and other duties – Warning
Evidence: § 1 "andere zumutbare Tätigkeiten … im gesamten Bundesgebiet". No place of work is specified. Although the wording "zumutbar" offers some limit, the employer would have a great deal of flexibility. Option: Clarify which locations exist and whether remote work is possible.
10. Salary, holiday, probation – unremarkable
The salary is about 24 €/hour, well above the minimum wage. 20 days of holiday is the statutory minimum, so there is no extra leave. A 6-month probation with 2 weeks' notice is in line with the law. The confidentiality clause is limited to trade secrets.
What is missing / cannot be checked
- No specific place of work stated (Nachweisgesetz)
- No information on the procedure for terminations or on the deadline for filing an unfair dismissal claim
- No arrangements for home office, travel or on-call duty
- How many locations the company actually has
What you can do
- Before signing, raise the contractual penalty, notice period and exclusion period (the most important points).
- Ask for a cap on overtime and for overtime pay.
- Negotiate a notification duty instead of a ban on side activities, and a graduated repayment clause.
- Consider additional leave (e.g. 25–30 days, which is common in IT) as a negotiating point.
- Have the contract reviewed by a specialist employment lawyer or your union.
Automated AI review, not checked by a human. This is not legal advice.